Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

whats the ruling here?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    whats the ruling here?

    Ok played a tournament, a 50 euro + 50 scalp, starting stack 23k and id grinded upto 30k without doing to much,playing active etc..

    Then this hand occurs im to the immediate right of dealer in seat 9, on the cut-off blinds 300-600, i make it 1300 pre with k-10, small blind flats playing 15k everyone else folds. Flop A,Ks,5s.. he check, i bet 1600, call...
    we both check rag turn
    finally he insta leads 3,100 on a j river...

    i tank and call, on doing so he announces the pot is yours...

    i throw my cards face down, dealer then drags them to bottom of muck, however there stoll viewable, and then starts moving chips to other player..i look round [my viewing had been blocked but i wasnt paying much attention] to see the hero with q3ss..

    i go wtf?? she goes u mucked u need to show cards to win hand...i pick out my 2 cards Nd turn them face up and kick up a fuss as iv never been to this 'casino' much before i argue that he had said pot was yours, and i never seen him flip over the q high like a boss..

    floor is called..whats the ruling??

    #2
    pretty straight forward you lose, if his hand is the only one tabled face up its simply his pot. cards speak

    They went in face down while he showed his is clearly a muck,

    Comment


      #3
      Never give the dealer your cards before he/she gives you the chips. It's a clear ( and old ) angleshoot from villain, but a cheap lesson for you.

      Each player's responsibility is to protect their hand, if you allow your hand to go into the muck then it's on you.
      Official Head Marshall of Waterford Gay Pride Festival 2015

      Comment


        #4
        Lol. You have thrown your hand away. Poker 101 fail

        Comment


          #5
          Very poor from the dealer but yes I guess its a cheap lesson never surrender a hand until your awarded the pot, and PAY attention when your playing

          Comment


            #6
            His pot. Show to win.

            Comment


              #7
              Originally posted by Alanfox View Post
              His pot. Show to win.
              Be last man with unmucked cards.
              ﴾͡๏̯͡๏﴿

              Comment


                #8
                Yeah true, but as a rule of thumb, just show your cards at showdown

                Comment


                  #9
                  Cheers i dont play much live- lesson learned...

                  dont play live ;-)

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by fumyname View Post
                    Cheers i dont play much live- lesson learned...

                    dont play live ;-)
                    where do you play then??

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Originally posted by Icarus152 View Post
                      Never give the dealer your cards before he/she gives you the chips. It's a clear ( and old ) angleshoot from villain, but a cheap lesson for you.
                      I'm not sure he was angle shooting tbh. He had a stab at the river, when hero calls he says words to the effect of "ah, you got me". Which is fine and pretty normal tbh. Then hero mucks. Villain didn't do anything sneaky or out of line imo.

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Originally posted by Mellor View Post
                        I'm not sure he was angle shooting tbh. He had a stab at the river, when hero calls he says words to the effect of "ah, you got me". Which is fine and pretty normal tbh. Then hero mucks. Villain didn't do anything sneaky or out of line imo.
                        Perhaps you're right, I read it as the villain arguing he'd mucked his hand and not the dealer.
                        Official Head Marshall of Waterford Gay Pride Festival 2015

                        Comment


                          #13
                          OMG i do not believe there are still people that do not that rule. on the showdown cards speak my friend. I show you muck , i can say " 3 high " and i will win if you muck.

                          On the other side if i see a player doing that 2nd time i will worn him

                          Comment

                          Working...
                          X